Part of Slepp's ProjectsPastebinTURLImagebinFilebin
Feedback -- English French German Japanese
Create Upload Newest Tools Donate


Question to Git mailing list
Monday, June 4th, 2007 at 11:43:42am UTC 

  1. Hello git users / maintainers / fans,
  3. My fellow projecteers and I watched a presentation given by Linus Torvalds on the advantages of git given at a google questions session sometime recently.
  5. Our project,, an open source firmware replacement project for digital audio players currently makes use of subversion for it's source code management system, but Linus's eloquent (though sometimes rather blunt) speech has made us question whether git is perhaps a better solution for us.
  7. On the whole, we like a lot of the features it offers but, we have a couple of issues which we've discussed, and so far have failed to come up with a decent resolution for them.
  9. 1) Due to the nature of our project, with multiple architectures supported, we strive to provide a binary build of our software with every commit to the subversion repository. This is so that we can provide a working firmware for the majority of our users that don't have the necessary know-how for cross-compiling and so forth.
  11. 2) Unlike the Linux Kernel, which Linus uses as a prime example of something git is very useful for, the Rockbox project has no central figurehead for anyone to consider as owning the "master" repository from which to build the "current" version of the Rockbox firmware for any given target.
  13. 3) With a central repository, for which we have a limited number of individuals having commit access, it's easy for us to automate a build based on each commit the repository receives.
  15. Given these three points, we wonder how we'd best achieve the same using git. As far as we can make out we'd need to appoint someone as a maintainer for a master repository whose job it is to co-ordinate pulls from people based on when they've made changes we wish to include in the latest version of our software. This sounds like a time consuming role for a project which is only staffed by volunteers.
  17. Can anyone offer any insights for us here?
  19. Bryan


Update the Post

Either update this post and resubmit it with changes, or make a new post.

You may also comment on this post.

update paste below
details of the post (optional)

Note: Only the paste content is required, though the following information can be useful to others.

Save name / title?

(space separated, optional)

Please note that information posted here will not expire by default. If you do not want it to expire, please set the expiry time above. If it is set to expire, web search engines will not be allowed to index it prior to it expiring. Items that are not marked to expire will be indexable by search engines. Be careful with your passwords. All illegal activities will be reported and any information will be handed over to the authorities, so be good.

comments powered by Disqus