Public feed #2454570

Editing Guidelines

public unlisted text v1 · immutable
Raw Edit
·published 2013-09-19 04:38 UTC
rendered paste body
Peer-Editing: Analysis-Evaluation Essay

As a peer-editor, you should be active in your reading. In the margins of the essay, as you read, write constructive comments that tell your peer what works for you and/or does not.

Writer/peer = the student writing the essay.
Author = the professional writer who wrote the article the student is analyzing.

Introduction:
o A hook.
o Check to see if the writer uses the full title of the article and the authors full name the first time they are mentioned, and subsequently the authors last name only.
o Optional: Does the student articulate the authors overall point? If so, circle it.
o Where does the student clearly articulate the specific key point(s) of the author that will be addressed in this paper? This is a must: Highlight or mark these sentences. Or if absent, provide suggestions.
o Verify that each sentence flows smoothly into the next, providing increasing specificity. The sentences should flow into the students focused thesis, usually placed at the end of the introduction. Think of the upside down triangle! Mark any moments in which the sentences dont quite flow, and provide suggestions.

Thesis: Double underline it and evaluate it. Make sure it meets the following criteria:
o Makes a judgment about the authors key point(s) that are being discussed. In other words, it should respond directly to these key points and articulate the students own position.
o Specifies/identifies vague words such as point, idea, claim, etc. Needs to tell us what the point, idea, claim IS.
o After reading the thesis, you should know where the writer is going. Fill in the rest of this sentence: Now, the writer is going to show me__________________________________.

Body Paragraphs: Each paragraph should include the following (if not provide suggestions):
o A topic sentence (needs to connect back to thesis as well as state what paragraph will be about). Underline each topic sentence. 
 Examples of support:
o Step-by-step explanation and reasoning. *This will be the key one for this paper as you will explain why and how the authors key points work and/or dont. These explanations, in turn, can be backed up with the following:
o Statistics, studies, facts
o Relevant and apt quotations
o Illustration
o Personal experience
 Explanations of how the support connects to the thesisthe so what. After providing the evidence, student should explain why/how its connected to the overall pointthe thesis. Highlight where student does this or provide suggestions.
 Concluding or clincher sentence (may be part of last bullet point).
 In the margins of the essay, write what each paragraph is about. This should be about one, at most two, points. If there are too many listed, brainstorm about categorizing these ideas into separate paragraphs.

Conclusion:
o Sums up key points
o Reiterates thesis without dully repeating it
o Drives the point homereally answers the so what! (This is your last chance!)
o Does NOT contain any new analysis or information (If so, identify it; it should be removed or moved into body.)

Other elements to look for:
o Transitions
o Hefty, healthy, hearty sandwiches
o No fallacies